Roofing Companies in New Port Richey, FL: An Honest Comparison (2026)
Roofing Companies in New Port Richey: What Homeowners Actually Need to Compare
Search "roofing companies New Port Richey" and you will get a long list of names, most with a star rating attached. The rating alone does not tell you much. A 4.5 with 400 reviews and a 4.5 with 40 reviews are not the same business, and a company's public listing rarely tells you who actually holds the state license, who is on your roof, or how the estimate was built.
Below is a straight, side by side look at six roofing companies that actively serve New Port Richey and the surrounding Pasco County market, including Scotti Family Roofing. Every rating and review count below was pulled live from each company's own Google Business profile on August 31, 2026, using the Google Places API, not copied from an older list or a third party directory. Review counts move week to week, so treat this as a snapshot, not a permanent ranking.
How We Chose and Ranked These Six
We ranked by Google star rating first, since that is the single number most homeowners actually look at before calling anyone. Where two companies tied on rating, we ordered them by review count, higher first, so the list stays transparent about what broke the tie.
On that measure, Scotti Family Roofing currently holds the highest Google rating of the six at 4.9 stars. We are not hiding the tradeoff that comes with it: Scotti Family Roofing is also one of the newer names in this market, and its review count is smaller than four of the five other companies here. A newer company simply has not had the years in the market to rack up hundreds of reviews yet. Both facts are true at once, and the table below shows all of it plainly.
We did not adjust, round, or drop a number to change the order. If a company's rating had been higher than ours, this article would say so, the same way our own family owned roofing company writeup for Bradenton put two competitors ahead of us on raw rating.
The Six Companies at a Glance
Ratings and review counts checked live on August 31, 2026, from each company's own Google Business profile.
| Company | Location | Google Rating | Google Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scotti Family Roofing | West Central Florida, serves Pasco County | 4.9 | 96 |
| The Roofing Company | New Port Richey | 4.8 | 495 |
| Veteran Owned Roofing | New Port Richey | 4.8 | 239 |
| Farrell Roofing | Port Richey | 4.5 | 364 |
| Mitchell and Sons Roofing | New Port Richey | 4.5 | 144 |
| Dale Webb Roofing | New Port Richey | 4.3 | 48 |
1. Scotti Family Roofing, 4.9 stars, 96 reviews
Scotti Family Roofing is a father and son shop covering West Central Florida, including the New Port Richey and Pasco County market. Vincent Scotti personally holds Florida roofing license CCC1337501 and is the licensed professional of record on the company's permits, meaning the name on the license is also the person signing off on your job, not a hired qualifier the company pays to use a license number. John Scotti brings more than 40 years of roofing experience to every estimate as a reviewer.
Current Google standing is 4.9 stars from 96 reviews, the highest rating of the six companies in this comparison, checked live on August 31, 2026. On review volume, Scotti Family Roofing sits near the smaller end of the group, ahead of only Dale Webb Roofing. That is the direct result of being one of the newer names working this market. We are not going to claim to be the biggest or the most reviewed shop in New Port Richey, because the numbers above show that is not true. What the numbers do show is the highest rating of the group, from a company where the estimator, the license holder, and the person you call back are the same people.
2. The Roofing Company, 4.8 stars, 495 reviews
The Roofing Company, based on State Road 54 in New Port Richey, has the highest review count in this comparison by a wide margin and has been BBB accredited since 2014. It is a full service shop handling shingle, tile, metal, flat roof, and coatings work for residential and commercial customers across the West Central Florida region. A shop with nearly 500 reviews at 4.8 stars has clearly built a large, consistent customer base over more than a decade in business.
3. Veteran Owned Roofing, 4.8 stars, 239 reviews
Veteran Owned Roofing operates out of US-19 in New Port Richey and ties The Roofing Company for the second highest rating in this comparison. The company name identifies its ownership directly. With 239 reviews at 4.8 stars, it has built a solid, established reputation in the New Port Richey market.
4. Farrell Roofing, 4.5 stars, 364 reviews
Farrell Roofing serves the New Port Richey area from Commerce Avenue in Port Richey, the neighboring city immediately west. Public listings tie the Farrell name to a multi-trade family of companies that also includes air conditioning services, not a roofing-only operation. At 4.5 stars from 364 reviews, it has a large, established customer base in the area.
5. Mitchell and Sons Roofing, 4.5 stars, 144 reviews
Mitchell and Sons Roofing, located on Osteen Road in New Port Richey, ties Farrell Roofing on rating at 4.5 stars with a smaller review count of 144. It is an established local roofing contractor serving the New Port Richey market.
6. Dale Webb Roofing, 4.3 stars, 48 reviews
Dale Webb Roofing, on Grand Boulevard in New Port Richey, is run by owner Dale Webb and has the smallest review count in this comparison at 48, with a 4.3 star rating. Public reviews describe Dale Webb personally inspecting jobs and walking customers through estimates, consistent with an owner still active in daily operations rather than a purely administrative role.
What a New Roof Actually Costs in the New Port Richey Area
Every roofing company above will give you a number. The honest answer is that the number depends almost entirely on material, roof size, and how much of the old roof and decking has to come off first. These ranges reflect mid-2026 material and labor rates in West Central Florida for a typical 1,500 to 2,500 square foot home. Ask any contractor you are comparing, including us, to break their quote down by these same categories so you are comparing apples to apples.
| Material | Typical Range (1,500-2,500 sq ft home) | Estimated Lifespan in Florida |
|---|---|---|
| Architectural / Dimensional Shingle | $10,000 to $20,000 | 25 to 30 years |
| Concrete Tile | $18,000 to $35,000 | 40 to 50 years |
| Clay Tile | $25,000 to $45,000 | 50 or more years |
| Standing Seam Metal | $20,000 to $40,000 | 40 to 60 years |
| Modified Bitumen (flat sections) | $6,000 to $12,000 | 15 to 25 years |
These ranges reflect mid-2026 material and labor rates in West Central Florida. Contact us for a current written quote specific to your home.
One material will not show up on any legitimate quote in Florida: standard 3-tab asphalt shingle. Standard 3-tab shingles are rated for roughly 60 to 70 mph winds and do not meet Florida Building Code wind uplift requirements anywhere in the state, New Port Richey included. Architectural or dimensional shingles rated 110 to 130-plus mph are the practical entry tier for a code compliant shingle roof here. If a company quotes 3-tab shingles for a Florida reroof, that is worth asking about directly before you sign anything.
Do You Need a Permit to Reroof in Pasco County?
Yes. Every residential reroof in Pasco County requires a building permit, and Pasco runs its permitting through the PascoGateway portal on the Accela system. This is not optional and it is not something a contractor can skip to save time.
Pasco County has one rule that trips up homeowners and out of area contractors: the Notice of Commencement has to be signed, notarized, and recorded with the Clerk of Courts before the permit application goes in, for any job over $5,000. In some neighboring counties the NOC is filed after the permit is issued. Pasco requires it first, as one of the required submittal documents on the permit application itself.
| Step | What It Involves |
|---|---|
| 1. Notice of Commencement | Signed and notarized, then recorded with the Pasco County Clerk of Courts, required before the permit application for jobs over $5,000. |
| 2. Permit application | Submitted through PascoGateway (Accela), including the recorded NOC, Florida product approval numbers, and manufacturer installation specifications, not just the approval number. |
| 3. Signed and sealed plans | Required only if the job involves structural work, plus special flood hazard area compliance where the property requires it. |
| 4. Inspection | Scheduled once the permit is issued and the roof work is complete, confirming the installation meets Florida Building Code. |
Common reasons Pasco County rejects a reroof permit application include plans that are not dimensioned or not signed and sealed, contractor information that is not current in the county's system, and incomplete owner information. A licensed contractor who regularly pulls Pasco permits should catch these before submission. If you want to verify a contractor's registration status directly, Pasco's contractor licensing office can be reached at contractorlicensing@mypasco.net or (727) 847-2411.
What a Written Roofing Estimate Should Actually Contain
Before comparing prices between any of the companies above, or anyone else, make sure you are comparing full, written estimates and not verbal ballpark numbers. A complete estimate for a Florida reroof should include the items below.
- Exact material and manufacturer, including the specific shingle, tile, or metal panel product line, not just "architectural shingle."
- Tear-off scope: how many existing layers are being removed, since Florida Building Code generally limits a roof to two layers before a full tear-off is required.
- Decking repair terms: the per-sheet price for replacing rotted or soft decking found once the old roof comes off, and how that gets approved before work continues.
- Underlayment and secondary water barrier method, since Florida code requires a sealed roof deck or an approved secondary water barrier on new construction and most reroofs.
- Permit and NOC handling: confirmation that the contractor is pulling the permit and recording the Notice of Commencement, not leaving it to the homeowner.
- Payment schedule and total price, in writing, with no verbal add-ons after the contract is signed.
Family Owned Shop vs. Larger Roofing Company: What Actually Changes
Two of the six companies above run several hundred reviews deep. That kind of volume usually means a larger crew count, more trucks running at once, and in some cases a dedicated sales team separate from the people doing the work. None of that makes a company bad. It does mean a homeowner is less likely to deal directly with the person whose name is on the state license.
A smaller shop like Scotti Family Roofing means the tradeoff runs the other way: fewer total jobs completed to date, and a smaller review count, in exchange for the license holder personally handling your permit and John Scotti reviewing every estimate before it goes out. Neither model is automatically the right answer for every homeowner. Ask directly who will be on your roof and whose name is on the permit, no matter which company you choose.
What Roof Repair Costs When You Are Not Replacing the Whole Roof
Not every roof problem in New Port Richey requires a full replacement. Storm damage, a single failed vent boot, or localized wear can often be repaired instead. Minor repairs, such as replacing a section of shingles or resealing a vent penetration, typically run $1,000 to $2,500. Decking repairs found during a repair or reroof generally run $75 to $120 per sheet of plywood or OSB replaced. Get a written scope for any repair, the same way you would for a full replacement, so you know exactly what was fixed and what was inspected but left alone.
Pasco County Is Not a High-Velocity Hurricane Zone, but Wind Rules Still Apply
Pasco County sits outside Florida's High-Velocity Hurricane Zone, which is limited to Miami-Dade and Broward counties. That does not mean roofing materials here are unregulated. Every roofing product installed in Pasco County still needs a valid Florida product approval number showing it meets the wind uplift rating required for this region, and Florida Building Code generally limits a roof to two layers of material before a full tear-off is required. New construction and most reroofs also require either a sealed roof deck or an approved secondary water barrier, on top of the primary underlayment, specifically because of Florida's hurricane exposure. Any company quoting work in New Port Richey should be able to show you the product approval number for the exact shingle, tile, or metal panel going on your roof, not just a general brand name.
How to Verify a Florida Roofing License Before You Sign Anything
Every company named in this comparison should carry an active Florida certified roofing contractor license. You can check any contractor's license status directly at myfloridalicense.com, searching by company name or license number. Look for three things: the license status shows "Current, Active," the license type matches the work being done, and the name on the license matches the company on your contract, not a different entity. Also ask directly whether the person who holds the license will be involved in your job, or whether the license is held by someone the company pays to qualify the business while a separate team runs the work. Neither answer disqualifies a company on its own, but you are entitled to know which one you are getting before you sign a contract.
Signs Your New Port Richey Roof May Need Attention Soon
Before you call any of the companies above, it helps to know what you are actually looking at. A few signs are worth a closer look, ideally from the ground with binoculars rather than climbing onto the roof yourself.
- Granule loss: shingles that look patchy or bald, or granules collecting in gutters and at downspout outlets, mean the protective layer is wearing thin.
- Curling or lifting shingle edges: a sign of age or heat damage that can let wind and water underneath during a storm.
- Cracked or slipped tiles: even one cracked tile can let water into the underlayment, and a missing tile is an active leak point.
- Streaking, staining, or ceiling spots inside the home: often the first sign homeowners actually notice, usually meaning water has already found a path through the roof system.
- Soft spots when walked on, or sagging sections: can mean decking underneath has already started to rot and needs to come out, not just be covered over.
- Roof age near or past 20 years for shingle, or manufacturer's stated lifespan for tile or metal: even a roof with no visible damage yet is worth a professional inspection once it approaches the end of its expected service life.
Any of these on their own does not necessarily mean a full replacement. A qualified inspection is the way to find out whether you are looking at a targeted repair or a larger job, and a written inspection report is worth keeping on file either way, including for insurance and resale purposes down the road.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which roofing company has the highest Google rating in New Port Richey right now?
Among the six companies compared here, Scotti Family Roofing currently has the highest Google rating at 4.9 stars, checked live on August 31, 2026. The Roofing Company and Veteran Owned Roofing follow at 4.8 stars each.
Which New Port Richey roofing company has the most Google reviews?
The Roofing Company has the most reviews in this comparison at 495, followed by Farrell Roofing at 364 and Veteran Owned Roofing at 239, all checked live on August 31, 2026.
How much does a roof replacement cost in New Port Richey, FL?
For a typical 1,500 to 2,500 square foot home, architectural shingle replacement generally runs $10,000 to $20,000, with tile and metal running higher. Exact cost depends on roof size, pitch, material, and how much decking needs replacing. Get a written estimate broken down by these factors rather than comparing single lump-sum numbers.
Do I need a permit to reroof in Pasco County?
Yes, every residential reroof in Pasco County requires a building permit through the PascoGateway portal. This applies regardless of which licensed contractor does the work.
Is a Notice of Commencement required for a Pasco County reroof?
Yes, for any job over $5,000. Pasco requires the NOC to be signed, notarized, and recorded with the Clerk of Courts before the permit application is submitted, not after the permit is issued.
Are 3-tab asphalt shingles legal on a Florida roof?
No. Standard 3-tab shingles are rated for roughly 60 to 70 mph winds and do not meet Florida Building Code wind uplift requirements anywhere in the state. Architectural or dimensional shingles rated 110 mph or higher are the minimum practical option for a code compliant shingle roof in New Port Richey.
What is the best roofing material for the New Port Richey climate?
Architectural shingles, concrete or clay tile, and standing seam metal are all code compliant options here, each with different upfront cost and lifespan. Tile and metal cost more upfront but generally last 40 years or longer in Florida's heat and storm exposure, while architectural shingles cost less upfront and typically last 25 to 30 years.
How long does a roof replacement take in Pasco County?
A straightforward shingle reroof on an average size home typically takes one to three days once the permit is issued and material is on site. Tile and metal roofs generally take longer. Weather and decking repairs found mid-job can extend the timeline.
How many roofing quotes should I get before choosing a contractor?
Most homeowners get two to three written, itemized estimates. Beyond that you are mostly comparing similar numbers with diminishing benefit. Focus more on comparing what each estimate actually includes than on collecting the largest possible number of quotes.
Does a new roof qualify for a wind mitigation insurance discount?
Often yes. A permitted reroof that passes county inspection generates documentation that can support a wind mitigation inspection, which may lower your homeowner's insurance premium. Ask your contractor for the permit and inspection paperwork, and ask your insurance agent about scheduling a wind mitigation inspection after the work is done.
What is the difference between a family owned roofing company and a larger roofing company?
A family owned shop typically means fewer total jobs running at once and a higher chance the state license holder is personally involved in your project. A larger company usually means more review volume, more crews available, and often a separate sales team. Ask any company directly who holds the license and whether that person will be involved in your specific job.
Does Scotti Family Roofing serve New Port Richey and Pasco County?
Yes. Scotti Family Roofing serves Pasco County, including New Port Richey, as part of its West Central Florida service area, handling residential reroofing, repairs, and tile, metal, and shingle replacement.
Frequently asked questions
Which roofing company has the highest Google rating in New Port Richey right now?
Among the six companies compared here, Scotti Family Roofing currently has the highest Google rating at 4.9 stars, checked live on August 31, 2026. The Roofing Company and Veteran Owned Roofing follow at 4.8 stars each.
Which New Port Richey roofing company has the most Google reviews?
The Roofing Company has the most reviews in this comparison at 495, followed by Farrell Roofing at 364 and Veteran Owned Roofing at 239, all checked live on August 31, 2026.
How much does a roof replacement cost in New Port Richey, FL?
For a typical 1,500 to 2,500 square foot home, architectural shingle replacement generally runs $10,000 to $20,000, with tile and metal running higher. Get a written estimate broken down by material, tear-off scope, and decking repairs.
Do I need a permit to reroof in Pasco County?
Yes, every residential reroof in Pasco County requires a building permit through the PascoGateway portal, regardless of which licensed contractor does the work.
Is a Notice of Commencement required for a Pasco County reroof?
Yes, for any job over $5,000. Pasco requires the NOC to be signed, notarized, and recorded with the Clerk of Courts before the permit application is submitted, not after.
Are 3-tab asphalt shingles legal on a Florida roof?
No. Standard 3-tab shingles are rated for roughly 60 to 70 mph winds and do not meet Florida Building Code wind uplift requirements anywhere in the state. Architectural shingles rated 110 mph or higher are the practical minimum.
What is the best roofing material for the New Port Richey climate?
Architectural shingles, concrete or clay tile, and standing seam metal are all code compliant options. Tile and metal cost more upfront but generally last 40 years or longer, while shingles cost less and typically last 25 to 30 years.
How long does a roof replacement take in Pasco County?
A straightforward shingle reroof typically takes one to three days once the permit is issued and material is on site. Tile and metal roofs generally take longer.
How many roofing quotes should I get before choosing a contractor?
Most homeowners get two to three written, itemized estimates and focus on comparing what each one actually includes rather than collecting as many quotes as possible.
Does a new roof qualify for a wind mitigation insurance discount?
Often yes. A permitted reroof that passes county inspection can support a wind mitigation inspection, which may lower your homeowner's insurance premium. Ask your contractor for the permit paperwork.
What is the difference between a family owned roofing company and a larger roofing company?
A family owned shop typically means fewer jobs running at once and a higher chance the license holder is personally involved in your project. A larger company usually means more review volume and often a separate sales team.
Does Scotti Family Roofing serve New Port Richey and Pasco County?
Yes. Scotti Family Roofing serves Pasco County, including New Port Richey, as part of its West Central Florida service area, handling reroofing, repairs, and tile, metal, and shingle replacement.
How can I check if a New Port Richey roofing contractor's license is active?
Search the company name or license number at myfloridalicense.com. Confirm the status shows Current, Active, and that the name on the license matches the company on your contract.
Is Pasco County a High-Velocity Hurricane Zone?
No. Florida's High-Velocity Hurricane Zone applies only to Miami-Dade and Broward counties. Pasco County still requires wind-rated, product-approved roofing materials under Florida Building Code, just under different specific requirements than the HVHZ.